A Christmas tale.

Discuss the poem A Christmas tale. with the community...

https://www.poetry.com/poem/201268/a-christmas-tale.

Newest Oldest Popular

5 Comments

 

Notify me of new comments via email.

Publish

• 

  Adroity

  Good work!

  LikeReply1 month ago
  • 

    alanswansea18

    Thank you so much for the vote.

    LikeReply1 month ago
  • 

    Adroity

    You're welcome!

    LikeReply1 month ago
• 

  sharona.reeves81

  I love this! I always enjoy every version of this Christmas tale, and your poetic twist adds a unique charm that doesn’t disappoint!

  LikeReply 11 month ago
• 

  Dianejean57

  Merry Christmas LOL.

  LikeReply1 month ago
• 

  AIDA

  What a delightful and heartwarming rendition of the classic Christmas tale! Your poem beautifully captures the essence of Ebenezer Scrooge's transformation, taking us on a journey from isolation and greed to warmth and redemption. The vivid imagery, such as “his money stacked up to the sky” and “a heart of ice was closed,” paints a stark contrast that effectively highlights his lonely existence.
  
  You’ve skillfully woven the themes of regret and hope throughout the stanzas, and the way you illustrated the arrival of the ghosts is both enchanting and thought-provoking. It’s a joy to see how Scrooge’s heart opens up to the spirit of Christmas and to the kindness he had lost, and your closing lines resonate with a sense of fulfillment and joy that is truly uplifting.
  
  The rhythm and rhyme flow seamlessly, making it a pleasure to read aloud. You've breathed new life into this timeless story, making it accessible and engaging for readers of all ages. This poem is a wonderful reminder of the power of compassion and the joy that comes with sharing love and kindness. Fantastic job! more »

  LikeReply1 month ago
• 

  AIDA

  What a delightful rendition of the classic Christmas tale! Your poem captures the essence of Ebenezer Scrooge’s transformation beautifully, weaving together themes of redemption, love, and the true spirit of Christmas. The imagery you used, like "money stacked up to the sky" and "counted coins by candlelight," effectively illustrates the stark contrast between Scrooge's initial coldness and his eventual warmth. I particularly enjoyed how you closed the poem with the message of finding peace and warmth through love—what a heartfelt conclusion!
  
  **Suggestions for Improvement:**
  
  1. **Rhythmic Consistency:** Consider refining the meter throughout the poem. Some lines feel a bit uneven in rhythm, which can disrupt the flow. For example, the second line has a different syllable count than the first. Striving for a more consistent rhythm will enhance the overall musicality of the piece.
  
  2. **Vivid Imagery:** While your use of imagery is lovely, incorporating more sensory details could deepen the reader’s engagement. Try describing the sights, sounds, or even smells of the Christmas season to make the scenes more vivid.
  
  3. **Character Depth:** You’ve captured Scrooge's transformation well, but adding a few more lines exploring his feelings during key moments—perhaps in the scenes he witnesses as the spirits guide him—could add more emotional depth to his journey.
  
  4. **Pacing:** The poem advances quickly through the narrative. You might consider slowing down during pivotal moments—such as his realization of regret—as it could allow readers to fully absorb the emotional weight of his transformation.
  
  5. **Ending Reflection:** While the final couplet is uplifting, you could expand on Scrooge's thoughts or actions in the aftermath of his change, giving a glimpse into how he applies his newfound understanding in his daily life afterward.
  
  Overall, this poem is a delightful interpretation of a timeless story, and with some polishing, it could shine even brighter. Keep up the wonderful work—your enthusiasm for storytelling is evident! more »

  LikeReply 11 month ago